Table of content:

Multiprocessing Vs. Multiprogramming: What's the Key Difference?

In the world of computing, programming refers to the process of writing instructions that a computer can follow to perform tasks, while processing involves executing those instructions to achieve desired outcomes. While processing refers to executing these instructions to get the desired outcome. As systems have become increasingly complex and resource-consuming, methods to extract maximum possible efficiency from CPUs have become sine qua non.

One such area of interest is the difference between multiprogramming and multiprocessing, which both focus on enhancing the performance of computer systems through task handling and task execution. In this article, we’ll delve into what these two concepts mean, how they differ from each other, and in what scenarios each is most effectively used.

Brief Introduction to Multiprogramming

Multiprogramming is defined as a technique whereby the CPU continuously switches among the several jobs that are being executed concurrently, with the objective of allowing a job to perform input or output operations while making good use of idle CPU time. This technique, therefore, utilizes CPU time that would otherwise be wasted.

Brief Introduction to Multiprocessing

Multiprocessing refers to the use of two or more CPUs within a single computer to work independently on different tasks or to work together on one task in order to increase the speed and power of the system.

Difference between Multiprocessing & Multiprogramming

Feature	Multiprocessing vs Multiprogramming
Definition	Multiprocessing: Executes multiple processes simultaneously using two or more CPUs. Multiprogramming: Loads multiple programs into memory and executes them one at a time through context switching.
Objective	Multiprocessing: Increase system performance with true parallel execution. Multiprogramming: Maximize CPU utilization by minimizing idle time.
Execution	Multiprocessing: Processes run concurrently on different CPUs. Multiprogramming: Processes run sequentially with quick context switches.
CPU Usage	Multiprocessing: Fully utilizes multiple CPUs. Multiprogramming: Efficient use of a single CPU.
Resource Requirement	Multiprocessing: Requires more hardware (multiple CPUs, more memory). Multiprogramming: Requires fewer resources.
Efficiency	Multiprocessing: Highly efficient for CPU-bound tasks. Multiprogramming: Efficient for I/O-bound tasks.
Complexity	Multiprocessing: More complex due to inter-process communication. Multiprogramming: Simpler to implement.
Throughput	Multiprocessing: Higher due to simultaneous task execution. Multiprogramming: Moderate, improves CPU utilization.
Example	Multiprocessing: Used in modern OS like Linux and Windows on multi-core CPUs. Multiprogramming: Seen in early batch processing systems.
Real Parallelism	Multiprocessing: Yes, true parallelism. Multiprogramming: No, only simulated.
Fault Tolerance	Multiprocessing: Better, the system continues if one CPU fails. Multiprogramming: Lower, one CPU failure affects all tasks.
System Cost	Multiprocessing: Higher due to extra hardware. Multiprogramming: Lower cost.
Scheduling	Multiprocessing: Uses symmetric/asymmetric multiprocessing techniques. Multiprogramming: Uses FCFS, Round Robin, Priority, etc.
Processor Dependency	Multiprocessing: Requires multiple processors. Multiprogramming: Works on single-processor systems.
Inter-process Communication (IPC)	Multiprocessing: Complex IPC via message passing/shared memory. Multiprogramming: Simpler IPC due to sequential execution.
Concurrency	Multiprocessing: Achieves true concurrency. Multiprogramming: Simulates concurrency.
Task Handling	Multiprocessing: Ideal for high-load parallel processing. Multiprogramming: Ideal for multi-user environments with many I/O operations.

What is Multiprogramming?

The operating system technique of multiprogramming allows several programs to reside in memory at once, with the CPU executing parts of each one sequentially through rapid switching. This method thus maximizes CPU utilization by preventing idle time during an I/O wait (disk reads, user input, etc.).

Primary Features of Multiprogramming

Efficient CPU Utilization: Ensures the CPU is always executing some part of a program, reducing idle time.
Concurrency: Enables multiple programs to appear as if they are running simultaneously, though only one is executed at a time by the CPU.
Job Scheduling: The OS uses scheduling algorithms to decide which program to execute next, optimizing performance.
Memory Management: Multiple programs share main memory, and the OS ensures efficient and safe memory allocation.
Reduced I/O Wait Time: While one program waits for I/O, another can use the CPU, making better use of system resources.

How Multiprogramming Works (Step-by-Step)

Loading Multiple Programs: The operating system loads several programs into memory at once.

Process Queuing: Each process is added to a ready queue, managed by the OS.

CPU Scheduling: The CPU picks one program from the queue to execute.

Context Switching: If a program requests I/O (like reading a file), the OS saves its state and loads another program’s state to continue processing.

I/O Completion: Once I/O is done, the waiting program is re-queued for execution.

Cycle Repeats: This cycle continues, giving an illusion of parallel processing and keeping the CPU busy at all times.

Applications of Multiprogramming

Batch Processing Systems: Ideal for systems that execute long-running tasks like billing, data entry, or payroll.
General-Purpose Operating Systems: Common in traditional desktop OSes like Windows and Linux for multitasking support.
Embedded Systems: Used in industrial controllers and embedded devices that need to handle multiple jobs effectively.
Scientific Computing: Enables concurrent data analysis and processing tasks without CPU idle time.

Benefits & Drawbacks of Using Multiprogramming

Let us consider some of the key benefits and drawbacks of multiprogramming:

Advantages	Disadvantages
Improved CPU Utilization: Multiprogramming keeps the CPU busy by loading multiple programs into memory and switching between them when one is waiting for I/O operations.	Complex Scheduling: Requires sophisticated scheduling algorithms to manage multiple programs efficiently, which increases OS complexity.
Increased Throughput: More programs are executed in a given period, resulting in higher system throughput.	Memory Management Issues: Efficient memory allocation and protection are challenging when multiple programs coexist in memory.
Reduced Idle Time: CPU rarely sits idle, as it can switch to another task when one is waiting for I/O, reducing wasted time.	Risk of Starvation: Some programs may be delayed indefinitely if the CPU keeps prioritizing others (poor scheduling can cause this).
Efficient Resource Utilization: Utilizes system resources like memory and CPU cycles effectively by overlapping computation and I/O.	Security Risks: One faulty or malicious program can potentially affect the operation or memory space of another if protection mechanisms fail.
Supports Multi-User Systems: Multiprogramming is suitable for environments where multiple users need to run tasks simultaneously.	Difficult Debugging: With multiple programs running concurrently, isolating and debugging errors can become more difficult.
Improved Responsiveness: It can reduce wait times for users, especially in time-sharing systems, by allowing background tasks to proceed.	Increased Overhead: Context switching and memory protection mechanisms introduce overhead that may slightly degrade performance.

What is Multiprocessing?

In multiprocessing, though the system has two or more processors that can execute multiple processes simultaneously, it can be different from multiprogramming, which works with only one CPU and is able to switch between different processes. Multiprocessing gives true parallelism: each CPU can run its own program and execute at the same time when needed.

Features of Multiprocessing

True Parallelism: Multiple processors can execute different processes simultaneously, improving performance.
Increased Throughput: More tasks can be completed in a shorter amount of time due to parallel execution.
Scalability: Multiprocessing systems can handle more processes as additional CPUs are added.
Reliability and Fault Tolerance: If one processor fails, others can continue executing tasks, enhancing system reliability.
Efficient Resource Utilization: Shared memory and resources are used effectively by all processors.

Examples of Multiprocessing Systems

Modern Operating Systems: Windows, Linux, and macOS support multiprocessing by utilizing multi-core CPUs.
Servers and Data Centers: Use multiprocessing to manage high volumes of client requests and background processes.
Scientific Simulations: Weather forecasting, physics simulations, and bioinformatics often require multiprocessing to handle large computations.
Rendering Software: Video editing and 3D rendering tools use multiprocessing to process frames and effects simultaneously.

Working of a Multiprocessing System

Multiple CPUs in One System: The system includes two or more processors connected via a shared bus or communication link.

Shared Memory Access: All processors can access the same memory space, or in some designs, have their own local memory.

Task Allocation: The operating system assigns different processes or threads to different processors.

Simultaneous Execution: Each CPU executes its assigned process at the same time as others.

Communication and Synchronization: CPUs coordinate using inter-process communication (IPC) and synchronization mechanisms to avoid conflicts, especially when accessing shared resources.

Explaining the Key Difference Between Multiprocessing and Multiprogramming

In this section, we will break down the fundamental differences between multiprocessing and multiprogramming, highlighting how each system handles tasks, hardware requirements, and performance characteristics:

Execution Approach

Multiprogramming uses a single CPU to switch between multiple programs, giving the illusion of parallelism. Only one program is executed at a time, and others wait in the background.

Multiprocessing, in contrast, uses multiple CPUs or cores to truly execute multiple programs or threads simultaneously, achieving actual parallel processing.

Hardware Requirements

Multiprogramming does not require special hardware—any system with sufficient memory and a single CPU can implement it.

Multiprocessing requires multiple CPUs or multi-core processors, along with supporting hardware like shared memory and interconnect systems to coordinate tasks between processors.

CPU Utilization

In multiprogramming, the CPU utilization is improved by switching to another program when the current one is waiting for I/O. It focuses on minimizing CPU idle time.

Multiprocessing, however, aims to maximize throughput by running multiple processes at once across different processors, making use of every available CPU.

Process Handling

Multiprogramming relies on context switching—the operating system saves the state of one process and loads another. This introduces overhead and is slower than true parallelism.

Multiprocessing doesn’t need frequent context switching between unrelated tasks, as each processor can handle its own workload independently, reducing overhead.

Complexity and Design

Multiprogramming systems are simpler to implement since they require only one CPU and basic scheduling.

Multiprocessing systems are more complex to design and manage because they require advanced CPU coordination, memory sharing, and process synchronization.

Performance

Multiprogramming improves perceived performance but doesn’t actually increase system speed. It works best for I/O-bound tasks.

Multiprocessing significantly boosts performance, especially for compute-intensive tasks, by truly dividing workloads between processors.

Conclusion

Multiprogramming and multiprocessing, two major concepts of modern computing, enhance computer system efficiency and performance, but differ in terms of their methods. Multiprogramming is a better CPU mode since several programs are allowed to be in memory, so that turns can be taken by the processor in executing them. This is appropriate for systems with hardware that is limited in resources and generally used in environments where work is primarily I/O-bound.

In contrast, multiprocessing lets multiple processors work on different tasks at the same time to achieve true parallelism and a considerable increase in system throughput, making it suitable for applications that are compute-intensive and for high-performance systems where speed and concurrency are an issue. Knowledge of the difference between multiprogramming and multiprocessing will enable system designers, developers, and IT professionals alike to select the model best suited for the system capabilities, performance goals, and application needs.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1. What is the main difference between multiprogramming and multiprocessing?

The primary difference lies in how tasks are executed and hardware is utilized. Multiprogramming allows multiple programs to reside in memory and run one at a time using a single CPU. It increases CPU efficiency by switching between programs during I/O operations. Multiprocessing, on the other hand, involves two or more processors working simultaneously to execute multiple programs or processes in parallel. It provides true concurrency and is more suitable for high-performance computing environments.

Q2. Can a system use both multiprogramming and multiprocessing?

Yes, modern operating systems often use a combination of both. A multiprocessing system (with multiple CPUs) can implement multiprogramming by allowing each processor to manage multiple programs that share the CPU in time slices. This hybrid approach maximizes both CPU utilization and parallel processing capabilities, enhancing the overall system performance and responsiveness.

Q3. Which is better: multiprogramming or multiprocessing?

It depends on the system’s purpose and hardware configuration. Multiprogramming is better suited for single-CPU systems where tasks involve frequent waiting (e.g., I/O operations), as it helps reduce CPU idle time. Multiprocessing is more powerful but requires additional hardware. It is preferred for systems that demand high-speed computation, multitasking, and real-time processing, such as servers, scientific simulations, and large-scale data processing platforms.

Q4. What are some real-life examples of multiprogramming and multiprocessing?

An example of multiprogramming is a desktop computer where a user is downloading a file while also listening to music and typing a document—these programs are not running simultaneously, but the CPU switches between them rapidly.

An example of multiprocessing is a modern server or a high-end personal computer with a multi-core processor running a video game, rendering a video, and updating antivirus definitions at the same time, with each task being processed in parallel on different cores.

Q5. Does multiprocessing always outperform multiprogramming?

Not necessarily. While multiprocessing can significantly improve performance for tasks that require intensive computation, it also demands more complex hardware and software coordination. If an application is not designed to take advantage of multiple processors or if tasks are mostly I/O-bound, the benefits of multiprocessing may not be fully realized. In such cases, multiprogramming can still offer efficient CPU usage without the added cost of multiprocessing infrastructure.

This article was contributed by Johns Joseph, Unstop Intern and Campus Ambassador.

Suggested reads:

The Writing Program

Unstop Campus Ambassadors

The writing program is a crew of student writers from arts and sciences, commerce, engineering, and MBA backgrounds. Fueled by caffeine, curiosity, and deadline-induced adrenaline–and driven by an unshakable love for learning–these jugglers turn knowledge into bite-sized brilliance.