Home Entrance Exam Prep CAT Versus XAT: Which Is A Tougher Nut to Crack?

Table of content:

CAT Versus XAT: Which Is A Tougher Nut to Crack?

For those aspiring to pursue an MBA in India, the most common dilemma is whether to appear for CAT or XAT. While CAT is the gateway to the prestigious IIMs, XAT opens doors to XLRI and many other top B-schools. Even though the two exams are broadly similar in objective, they differ significantly in terms of structure, marking, and difficulty. Here's an updated 2025 breakdown of CAT vs XAT to help you make an informed decision.

Overview of CAT and XAT

The Common Admission Test (CAT) is one of India’s most prestigious MBA entrance exams, conducted annually by the Indian Institutes of Management (IIMs) on a rotational basis. A high CAT score can open doors not just to the 20 IIMs, but also to over 1,000 other top-tier B-schools across the country, such as FMS Delhi, MDI Gurgaon, SPJIMR Mumbai, and IITs offering management programs. CAT is known for its fast-paced structure, sectional time limits, and a strong emphasis on quantitative ability, verbal reasoning, and data interpretation.

On the other hand, the Xavier Aptitude Test (XAT) is conducted by XLRI Jamshedpur, one of India’s top private B-schools. While it is primarily a gateway to XLRI’s flagship management programs, over 160 institutes accept XAT scores, including IMT Ghaziabad, TAPMI, XIMB, and others. XAT distinguishes itself from CAT by including a Decision-Making section and often an Essay Writing component (depending on the year), evaluating a candidate’s judgment, ethics, and practical reasoning skills—traits that are crucial for future business leaders.

In essence, both exams are highly respected and open up a wide range of opportunities, but they differ significantly in structure, focus areas, and the type of aptitude they test.

Important Dates for 2025–26 Cycle

Event CAT 2025 XAT 2026
Registration Opens August 1, 2025 July 10, 2025
Registration Closes September 13, 2025 December 5, 2025
Admit Card Release November 5, 2025 December 20, 2025 (Tentative)
Exam Date November 30, 2025 January 4, 2026 
Criteria CAT 2025 XAT 2025
Conducting Body IIM Kozhikode (in 2025) XLRI Jamshedpur
Exam Date November 30, 2025 January 04, 2026
Eligibility Bachelor’s degree with ≥50% marks (45% for SC/ST/PwD) Bachelor’s degree (minimum 3 years)
Mode of Exam Online (Computer-Based Test) Online (Computer-Based Test)
Exam Duration 2 hours (120 minutes) 3 hours (180 minutes)
Sections VARC, DILR, QA Decision Making, Verbal & Logical Ability, QA & DI, General Knowledge
Total Questions 68 (24 VARC + 22 DILR + 22 QA)

95 (25 VALR + 21 DM + 28 QA&DI + 20 GK)

Total Marks 204 (68 × 3 marks each) 95 marks (1 mark per question; GK not counted in total score)
Marking Scheme +3 for correct
−1 for incorrect MCQs
No negative for TITA
+1 for correct
−0.25 for incorrect
−0.10 for >8 unattempted
No negative in GK
Type of Questions MCQ and TITA (Type In The Answer) MCQ only (Unlike in previous years, essay writing has been scrapped from the exam but will be conducted during the XLRI selection process.)
Sectional Time Limits Yes – 40 mins per section (For PwD: 53 mins) No – overall 180 mins (no sectional timing)
Difficulty Level Moderate to Difficult Moderate to Difficult (Decision-making is a key differentiator)
Colleges Accepting Score 20 IIMs  and 1000+ B-Schools XLRI and 160+ institutes

Both CAT and XAT are challenging in their own ways. However:

  • CAT requires speed, time management, and strong grasp across three core areas with tight sectional limits.
  • XAT tests broader aptitude, with Decision Making and GK sections adding complexity. The lack of sectional time limits also demands self-paced discipline.

Special Focus: Decision-Making in XAT

The Decision-Making section in XAT is unique and crucial. It presents real-life scenarios where aspirants must make judgment-based decisions. Tips:

  • Avoid emotional bias and use logic and fairness.
  • Use elimination techniques to rule out close options.
  • Practice past year papers for familiarity.

Note: The GK section is not counted in the overall XAT percentile, but it is considered during the final selection process by XLRI and some other institutes. So, it’s important to score decently in this section.

CAT vs XAT: Frequently Asked Questions

Q1. Which exam is easier – CAT or XAT?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. CAT is shorter but has strict sectional time limits. XAT is longer and includes Decision Making and GK, which many find tricky. Your comfort with reading comprehension, logical reasoning, and decision analysis should guide your choice.

Q2. Is XAT accepted by IIMs?

No, XAT scores are not accepted by IIMs. IIMs only consider CAT scores for admission. However, many top B-schools like XLRI, XIMB, TAPMI, IMT, and GIM accept XAT scores.

Q3. Can I appear for both CAT and XAT?

Yes, absolutely. Many aspirants take both exams to broaden their admission chances. The exams are scheduled over a month apart, allowing time for preparation between them.

Q4. Is there any negative marking in XAT?

Yes, XAT has negative marking:

–0.25 for every incorrect answer

–0.10 penalty if you leave more than 8 questions unattempted

No negative marking in the General Knowledge section

Q5. What are some other MBA entrance exams in India?

  • SNAP – Symbiosis
  • NMAT – NMIMS
  • CMAT – AICTE
  • MAT – AIMA

Q6. What is the major difference in exam structure between CAT and XAT?

CAT has 3 sections: VARC, DILR, and QA with sectional time limits. XAT includes Decision Making and General Knowledge and has no sectional timing, giving candidates flexibility in managing time.

Final Takeaway

Selecting between CAT and XAT isn’t only about which exam is tougher but about aligning with the one that fits your strengths and thinking style.

CAT is ideal for those who thrive under strict time pressure and can maintain accuracy while solving quantitative and verbal questions quickly. It focuses on speed, precision, and sectional efficiency, making it suitable for candidates who are methodical and time-driven.

XAT, on the other hand, tests a broader spectrum of skills—analytical reasoning, decision-making, and verbal ability, without sectional time limits (except in some sections). It rewards test-takers who think critically, adapt to new question styles, and apply judgment in ambiguous scenarios. The Decision-Making section is unique to XAT and often a key differentiator.

If you're someone who excels in handling ethical dilemmas, logical thinking, and real-world judgment calls, XAT could play to your advantage. But if your strength lies in fast, structured problem-solving, CAT might be the better route.

In short: Know your strengths. Understand what each test demands. And then prepare accordingly.

Suggested Reads:
TAGS
XAT CAT MBA MBA Aspirants XLRI
Updated On: 12 Aug'25, 07:14 PM IST